Insight — A Treatment Plan Must Also See the Future
Clinical Insight
Prosthetic decision-making based on anticipating failure, not on treating the present condition.
Before any treatment plan, «what we see today» alone is not enough; we must also anticipate the functional future of the tooth. Sometimes the best decision is to prevent a certain future failure — even if it is not an easy decision in the moment.
Clinical summary
The patient presented needing implants for the 4 and 5 sites. Tooth 3 had recently undergone root canal treatment, and the patient expected a crown to be placed on this tooth as well.
Radiographic and clinical evaluation revealed:
- There is no palatal ferrule (a critical factor in the upper canine).
- The mesial ferrule has also been lost.
- The position of the canine is such that it is always under severe lateral forces.
On the surface, this tooth could be kept, a post and core placed, and a crown made. But this was only «looking at today».
The decision pathway: not only looking at the present
In a team evaluation with the periodontist, it became clear that creating a palatal ferrule:
- requires extensive bone removal,
- weakens the periodontal future,
- and even with the best restorative work, the biomechanics of the tooth will not be reliable.
This was the decision point: how much is the future of this tooth worth in the patient's treatment plan?
The patient was about to invest in two implants right now. If we kept the canine and it later failed, the patient would again bear new cost, treatment, and risk.
Given the strategic position of the canine, the high probability of future failure, and the fact that the patient was already in the implant-placement phase, the best decision was removing tooth 3 and designing the implants at the 3 and 5 sites.
The key point
A good treatment plan is not just today's radiograph and clinical exam; the functional future must also be seen.
Sometimes choosing the best means giving up a treatment that is seemingly possible but that, in the future, creates cost, risk, and certain failure.
In this case, by seeing the future:
- the patient was saved from the inevitable failure of the canine,
- the functional risk was eliminated,
- and a stable plan with implants at 3 and 5 was created for them.
The content of this page is intended for the educational use of dentists and dental students.